| Time | Team | Call | Penalized | Drawn By |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 6:33 | TOR | HOLDING MINOR · 2 min | Connor Dewar C · Depth | Jacob Bryson D · Bottom Pair |
| P1 8:47 | TOR | DELAY_OF_GAME MINOR · 2 min | Connor Dewar C · Depth | - |
| P1 17:11 | BUF | INTERFERENCE MINOR · 2 min | Connor Clifton D · Middle Pair | Pontus Holmberg |
| P2 4:55 | BUF | TRIPPING MINOR · 2 min | Zach Benson L · Middle 6 | William Nylander R · Top 6 |
| P2 9:19 | TOR | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Auston Matthews C · Top 6 | Zach Benson L · Middle 6 |
| P2 14:28 | TOR | DELAY_OF_GAME MINOR · 2 min | Jake McCabe D · Top Pair | - |
| P3 5:42 | TOR | INTERFERENCE MINOR · 2 min | Simon Benoit D · Middle Pair | Victor Olofsson L · Depth |
| P3 7:44 | BUF | HIGH_STICKING MINOR · 2 min | Jeff Skinner L · Middle 6 | TJ Brodie D · Top Pair |
| P3 16:13 | TOR | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Jake McCabe D · Top Pair | Jordan Greenway L · Middle 6 |
| P3 19:04 | BUF | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | JJ Peterka R · Middle 6 | - |
| P3 19:04 | TOR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Auston Matthews C · Top 6 | - |
| P3 19:04 | BUF | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Jordan Greenway L · Middle 6 | - |
| P3 19:04 | TOR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Bobby McMann C · Depth | - |
| P3 19:04 | BUF | BOARDING MINOR · 2 min | Rasmus Dahlin D · Top Pair | TJ Brodie D · Top Pair |
| P3 19:04 | TOR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | TJ Brodie D · Top Pair | - |
| P3 19:04 | BUF | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Tage Thompson C · Top 6 | - |
| P3 19:04 | TOR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Tyler Bertuzzi L · Middle 6 | - |
| P3 19:04 | TOR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Mark Giordano D · Middle Pair | - |
| P3 19:04 | BUF | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Alex Tuch R · Top 6 | - |
| P3 19:04 | BUF | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Rasmus Dahlin D · Top Pair | - |
| P3 19:04 | BUF | UNSPORTSMANLIKE MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Owen Power D · Top Pair | - |
| P3 20:00 | BUF | SLASHING MINOR · 2 min | Dylan Cozens C · Middle 6 | Matthew Knies L · Depth |
