| Time | Team | Call | Penalized | Drawn By |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 6:14 | NYR | BOARDING MINOR · 2 min | Chris Kreider L · Top 6 | Seth Jarvis R · Top 6 |
| P1 9:56 | CAR | ROUGHING MINOR · 2 min | Tony DeAngelo D · Middle Pair | Will Cuylle L · Depth |
| P1 10:58 | NYR | GOALIE_INTERFERENCE MINOR · 2 min | Matt Rempe C · 4th Line |
Frederik Andersen G · Backup |
| P1 11:13 | CAR | ROUGHING MINOR · 2 min | Andrei Svechnikov R · Middle 6 | Jacob Trouba D · Top Pair |
| P1 11:13 | NYR | ROUGHING MINOR · 2 min | Jacob Trouba D · Top Pair | Andrei Svechnikov R · Middle 6 |
| P1 16:14 | CAR | CROSS_CHECKING MINOR · 2 min | Evgeny Kuznetsov C · Middle 6 | Adam Fox D · Top Pair |
| P2 2:37 | NYR | CROSS_CHECKING MINOR · 2 min | Jacob Trouba D · Top Pair | Stefan Noesen R · Depth |
| P2 15:14 | NYR | SLASHING MINOR · 2 min | Adam Fox D · Top Pair | Andrei Svechnikov R · Middle 6 |
| P3 19:19 | NYR | DELAY_OF_GAME MINOR · 2 min | Vincent Trocheck C · Top 6 | - |
| P3 19:25 | CAR | TRIPPING MINOR · 2 min | Andrei Svechnikov R · Middle 6 | Ryan Lindgren D · Middle Pair |
