| Time | Team | Call | Penalized | Drawn By |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 6:01 | PIT | TOO_MANY_MEN MISCONDUCT · 2 min | - | - |
| P1 18:56 | NYR | ROUGHING MINOR · 2 min | Ben Harpur D · Bottom Pair | Evgeni Malkin C · Top 6 |
| P1 18:56 | PIT | ROUGHING MINOR · 2 min | Evgeni Malkin C · Top 6 | Ben Harpur D · Bottom Pair |
| P1 18:56 |
| PIT |
BOARDING MINOR · 2 min |
Evgeni Malkin C · Top 6 |
Braden Schneider D · Middle Pair |
| P2 4:35 | NYR | ROUGHING MINOR · 2 min | Vincent Trocheck C · Top 6 | Drew O'Connor L · 4th Line |
| P2 10:17 | NYR | DELAY_OF_GAME MINOR · 2 min | Igor Shesterkin G · Starter | - |
| P2 14:07 | NYR | TRIPPING MINOR · 2 min | Chris Kreider L · Top 6 | Jake Guentzel C · Top 6 |
| P3 5:05 | PIT | HIGH_STICKING MINOR · 2 min | Brian Dumoulin D · Top Pair | Vincent Trocheck C · Top 6 |
| P3 7:01 | NYR | HIGH_STICKING MINOR · 2 min | Barclay Goodrow C · Middle 6 | Chad Ruhwedel D · Bottom Pair |
| P3 10:33 | PIT | SLASHING MINOR · 2 min | Jeff Carter C · Depth | Filip Chytil C · Middle 6 |
| P3 12:16 | NYR | TRIPPING MINOR · 2 min | Barclay Goodrow C · Middle 6 | Josh Archibald R · Depth |
| P3 20:00 | PIT | SLASHING MINOR · 2 min | Josh Archibald R · Depth | Kaapo Kakko R · Middle 6 |
