| Time | Team | Call | Penalized | Drawn By |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 0:19 | NSH | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Cole Smith R · Depth | Braden Schneider D · Middle Pair |
| P1 4:07 | NSH | INSTIGATOR MINOR · 2 min | Andreas Englund D · Bottom Pair | Matt Rempe C · 4th Line |
| P1 4:07 | NYR | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Matt Rempe C · 4th Line |
Andreas Englund D · Bottom Pair |
| P1 4:07 | NSH | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Andreas Englund D · Bottom Pair | Matt Rempe C · 4th Line |
| P1 4:07 | NSH | INSTIGATOR MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Andreas Englund D · Bottom Pair | - |
| P1 4:07 | NYR | ELBOWING MINOR · 2 min | Matt Rempe C · 4th Line | Cole Smith R · Depth |
| P1 8:51 | NSH | TRIPPING MINOR · 2 min | Steven Stamkos C · Top 6 | Mika Zibanejad C · Top 6 |
| P2 0:26 | NSH | TRIPPING MINOR · 2 min | Jonathan Marchessault C · Middle 6 | Mika Zibanejad C · Top 6 |
| P2 6:37 | NYR | DELAY_OF_GAME MINOR · 2 min | Calvin de Haan D · Middle Pair | - |
| P2 9:55 | NSH | DELAY_OF_GAME MINOR · 2 min | Justin Barron D · Middle Pair | - |
| P3 3:41 | NYR | GOALIE_INTERFERENCE MINOR · 2 min | Sam Carrick C · Depth | Justus Annunen G · Rookie |
| P3 5:00 | NSH | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Nick Blankenburg D · Middle Pair | Mika Zibanejad C · Top 6 |
