| Time | Team | Call | Penalized | Drawn By |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 0:02 | NJD | UNSPORTSMANLIKE GAME_MISCONDUCT · 10 min | John Marino D · Top Pair | - |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE GAME_MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Barclay Goodrow C · Depth | - |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE GAME_MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Jacob Trouba D · Top Pair | - |
| P1 0:02 | NJD |
FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min |
John Marino D · Top Pair |
K'Andre Miller D · Top Pair |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Barclay Goodrow C · Depth | Kevin Bahl D · Middle Pair |
| P1 0:02 | NJD | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Curtis Lazar C · Depth | Jimmy Vesey L · Depth |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Jimmy Vesey L · Depth | Curtis Lazar C · Depth |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | K'Andre Miller D · Top Pair | John Marino D · Top Pair |
| P1 0:02 | NJD | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Kevin Bahl D · Middle Pair | Barclay Goodrow C · Depth |
| P1 0:02 | NJD | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Kurtis MacDermid L · 4th Line | Matt Rempe C · 4th Line |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Jacob Trouba D · Top Pair | Chris Tierney C · 4th Line |
| P1 0:02 | NJD | UNSPORTSMANLIKE GAME_MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Chris Tierney C · 4th Line | - |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE GAME_MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Matt Rempe C · 4th Line | - |
| P1 0:02 | NJD | UNSPORTSMANLIKE GAME_MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Kevin Bahl D · Middle Pair | - |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | UNSPORTSMANLIKE GAME_MISCONDUCT · 10 min | K'Andre Miller D · Top Pair | - |
| P1 0:02 | NJD | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Chris Tierney C · 4th Line | Jacob Trouba D · Top Pair |
| P1 0:02 | NJD | UNSPORTSMANLIKE GAME_MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Kurtis MacDermid L · 4th Line | - |
| P1 0:02 | NYR | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Matt Rempe C · 4th Line | Kurtis MacDermid L · 4th Line |
| P1 0:54 | NYR | BOARDING MINOR · 2 min | Jack Roslovic C · Middle 6 | Jesper Bratt L · Top 6 |
| P1 4:27 | NYR | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Will Cuylle L · Depth | Dawson Mercer C · Middle 6 |
| P1 4:27 | NJD | INSTIGATOR MINOR · 2 min | Dawson Mercer C · Middle 6 | Will Cuylle L · Depth |
| P1 4:27 | NJD | FIGHTING_MAJOR MAJOR · 5 min | Dawson Mercer C · Middle 6 | Will Cuylle L · Depth |
| P1 4:27 | NYR | BOARDING MINOR · 2 min | Will Cuylle L · Depth | Brendan Smith D · Middle Pair |
| P1 4:27 | NJD | INSTIGATOR MISCONDUCT · 10 min | Dawson Mercer C · Middle 6 | - |
| P1 9:22 | NJD | DELAY_OF_GAME MISCONDUCT · 2 min | - | - |
| P1 15:56 | NJD | CROSS_CHECKING MINOR · 2 min | Tomas Nosek L · Depth | Braden Schneider D · Middle Pair |
| P1 19:00 | NYR | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Vincent Trocheck C · Top 6 | Ondrej Palat L · Middle 6 |
| P2 15:19 | NYR | TRIPPING MINOR · 2 min | Chris Kreider L · Top 6 | Curtis Lazar C · Depth |
| P3 13:38 | NJD | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Brendan Smith D · Middle Pair | Jack Roslovic C · Middle 6 |
