| Time | Team | Call | Penalized | Drawn By |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 13:28 | NYR | HOLDING MINOR · 2 min | K'Andre Miller D · Top Pair | Radim Zohorna L · 4th Line |
| P1 16:07 | NYR | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Alexis Lafrenière L · Middle 6 | Marcus Pettersson D · Top Pair |
| P2 6:36 | PIT | INTERFERENCE MINOR · 2 min | John Ludvig D · Bottom Pair |
Braden Schneider D · Middle Pair |
| P3 1:55 | NYR | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Blake Wheeler R · Depth | Alex Nylander L · Middle 6 |
| P3 2:42 | PIT | SLASHING MINOR · 2 min | Erik Karlsson D · Top Pair | Chris Kreider L · Top 6 |
| P3 9:00 | NYR | DELAY_OF_GAME MINOR · 2 min | Jacob Trouba D · Top Pair | - |
| P3 11:10 | NYR | HOOKING MINOR · 2 min | Barclay Goodrow C · Depth | Ryan Graves D · Middle Pair |
| P3 17:17 | PIT | TRIPPING MINOR · 2 min | Erik Karlsson D · Top Pair | Blake Wheeler R · Depth |
